На главнуюНовости и политикаПохожее видеоЕще от: CNN

Justice Antonin Scalia talks about Roe v. Wade.

Оценок: 1847 | Просмотров: 318935
Justice Antonin Scalia talks to CNN's Piers Morgan about Roe v. Wade and abortion rights. For more CNN videos, check out our YouTube channel at http://www.youtube.com/cnn Or visit our site at http://www.cnn.com/video/
Html code for embedding videos on your blog
Текстовые комментарии (1172)
jeneen beard (17 часов назад)
along came a non citizen who was voted in by fools,and then this great man suffered his life for his constitutional views what which he was nominated
Bobby Robby (1 месяц назад)
Women have no right to kill her baby. The constitution does not give the right for a woman to kill her baby.
Maria Callous (1 месяц назад)
Scalia is anti abortion and anti birth control. I think he needs to go further. I think he needs to tell us who should breed and who should not breed. Who should engage in sexual behaviors and who should not and think he needs to go further than that and not say whomever is married in the church is allowed to breed. I need to know exactly who should and should not. Catholics only? I need the full score on this one. It would be a better world of he would just tell us. I think he needs to tell is exactly in as many words as possible who is going to hell and who isn't.
Alisha L (2 месяца назад)
Scalia for the win
Micheal Ram (2 месяца назад)
Roe vs Wade is not about right to abortion. Those rights are defined uniquely by the states. The case is about a father’s choice and say in it. Since then, irresponsible women get abortion like candy in a bar.
German Gutierrez (2 месяца назад)
A big idiot like Pierce Morgan talking to a brilliant man looks even more little. Pierce, look at your own country, it's a mess because of people like YOU.
Joseph charles (2 месяца назад)
Judge scalia is not smart. He avoided the question that woman in the 1800"s didnt have many rights to vote, in education, property rights, marriage rights, etc. He is devoid of any feelings, A Typical Republican right lean midget.. Thank god he is gone.. VOTE LIBERAL PLEASE
Spy Door Man (2 месяца назад)
Its like a father talking to his 5 year old boy.
ninuxy (2 месяца назад)
"Left to Democratic choice"! So the rule of majority over others? How about gay marriage? GTFOH with your inverted bullshit.
montanadoctor (2 месяца назад)
Morgan wants to have his liberal approval of abortion be apparent during this interview. He knows NOTHING of our constitution, like most libtards.
Psalm 27 (2 месяца назад)
"changing times"? Murder is murder.
John Robie (3 месяца назад)
Piers doesn't seem to understand the concept of "rule of law" vs judicial activism. The role of the justice system is to make sure the law as written is being enforced, not re-interpreting / rewriting law based on today's needs / wants / desires / popular opinion. If you need an updated law, go through the proper channels (legislative branch). What a self-righteous ass.
Mr. Papageorgio (3 месяца назад)
5 of the 7 that voted in favor of Roe were nominated by Republicans. So as a Republican we have no one to blame but ourselves.
Jon Jonzz (3 месяца назад)
So, an unborn, innocent child is not a person, according to "feminists", Democrats and the Left. Yet, if someone murders a pregnant woman, they are charged with 2 murders, in the majority of States. Abortion needs to be a State's Rights decision, not the SCOTUS. And, if any states allow it, the cost should be born by the person deciding to murder the child, not taxpayer's money.
one-scientist's-pov (3 месяца назад)
The SCOTUS decision regarding Roe v Wade was partly based on the right to privacy with respect to a woman's body.
one-scientist's-pov (3 месяца назад)
Morgan also claim women's rights with respect to abortion. The developing fetus does not have maternal identity, it's unique set of cell surface immunogenic antigens determines identity. This is the reason immune system suppressive drugs are given to organ transplant recipients, even if the donor is the mother.
one-scientist's-pov (3 месяца назад)
Morgan confuses the constitution with the political desires of the courts within the context of their respective times. In other words, the men who made decision to discriminate did so for their own selfish reasons, not because their actions were justified by constitutional jurisprudence.
Flightof2Owls (3 месяца назад)
He managed to find the idea that money equals free speech in the constitution, which is not there at all. That’s more of a stretch than a right to a legal abortion deriving from privacy or due process. The constitution is there to be interpreted in the PEOPLE’s favor, not to subjugate them to the will of the long dead “founding fathers” as if they were gods. This fanatic should have joined the Church not tried to impose his religion (corporatism) on the people.
Pierre Dakota (3 месяца назад)
Oh! Dear you are right about my understanding of the laws and justice. Power equals money. You got money and you got justice and it is mostly helpful if you are white male. Plain and simple. Ha ha ha ha life
Maurice Walker (3 месяца назад)
I lean left on most issues, and I'm certainly pro-choice, but Scalia's words during the last thirty seconds are extremely profound...and I think I agree with him.
Made for Man Caves (3 месяца назад)
Piers Morgan managed to prove himself a complete moron in less than a minute.
Pierre Dakota (3 месяца назад)
Wow. There was nothing in the constitutions that say a plant can be made federally illegal. Yet we found a way to abolish weeds. There is a fraud big time here
kwazooplayingguardsman (3 месяца назад)
because you a have massive misunderstanding of how laws work.
BlitzinLB27 (3 месяца назад)
Rare, Legal and Safe!!!
Rich Henry (3 месяца назад)
A states citizens should have the choice to decide whether abortion should be banned or not.
Flightof2Owls (3 месяца назад)
Rich Henry No they shouldn’t, not unless the state citizens accept all responsibility for the unwanted children born as a result, and at least guarantee basic needs and education for all of them and the mothers, and fathers. We don’t even have universal healthcare yet, or a living wage or guaranteed family leave, for people who are already born: how are we going to ensure they have a life worth living once they exit the birth canal?
Miller Theory (3 месяца назад)
Piers says women didn’t have any rights and that nobody considered women’s rights. Lol. First, he’s assuming abortion is a woman’s right. Second, by his logic women wouldn’t even be allowed to use the bathroom, since it wasn’t in the constitution. Third, of course women had rights. They just didn’t vote because that was considered a man’s role. Man liberals are blatant lying murderers.
ATube YouAre (3 месяца назад)
So much of the feminist bitterness in the US today comes from two major sources, (1) women who have had abortions and (2) women who kept delaying motherhood until they were too old to get pregnant and now live in utter bitterness and regret as they see other women with loving families and a legacy that is far more valuable than a career. Foolish women who swallowed the lied that all their problems were caused by men. Now they are gnashing their teeth and wailing from the hell that exists inside their minds.
ATube YouAre (3 месяца назад)
The irony of the millions of abortions carried out in the US and the need to import millions of migrants BORN to non-US citizens in order to sustain jobs and grow the economy. US women have aborted their own to achieve what? 90% of abortions have absolutely nothing to do with rape and everything to do with consensual sex. Yes, women who chose to have sex, who wanted to have sex, who agreed to have sex, and who later used abortion as a form of birth control because their life wasn't PERFECT yet, the time wasn't ideal yet to have a baby! These women need to be given a history lesson and look at the billions of women in the past who gave birth to children in ordinary and extraordinary circumstances and went on to love and cherish and raise wonderful kids.
bakshay (3 месяца назад)
Scalia was a complete fraud. Not a great thinker or juris. Simply a lunk headed right wing Catholic.
javier castellon (3 месяца назад)
The Democrat party is not pro -women.  Abortion is linked to regret, anxiety, low self worth, infertility, promiscuity, addictions and even suicide.  Abortion kills one, hurts another.
javier castellon (3 месяца назад)
Is spiritual warfare.  Good VS Evil.  Life VS Death.  Abortion, the intentional premeditated killing of the innocent for convenience and ignorance, on the part of the woman.  Money and politics, for democrat politicians.  As simple as that.  60 million babies killed in the place they should be protected the most...   inside their own mothers.  Democrats are not pro-women.  Abortion is linked to regret, anxiety, low self worth, depression, promiscuity, infertility, addictions and even suicide.  Abortion kills one, hurts another.
freethinker4liberty (3 месяца назад)
It truly is incredible how much of the constitution has been stomped on, allowed by the American people. And now, in 2018, it is not only the popular and "moral" view to stomp on the 2nd amendment, but also the 1st. In a short few years, if you allow it, America will not even be a shell of its former self, it will just be another failed experiment that is far worse than when it was in the experiment. The fact 50% of Americans want the end of American exceptionalism is absolutely crazy, that they want to rip up the constitution and give the feds absolute power is insane. I, as your Canadian neighbour, shutter at the thought, I don't even know if I should dream about coming to America anymore. Trump has made it a bit better but probably only temporary.
javier castellon (3 месяца назад)
Unfortunately you are right.
Mia Lavatta (3 месяца назад)
Roe v wade was a built on lie! She lied! I’m pro choice if there are people that can have a child ripped out the body they do not need to breed!
Robert Hill (3 месяца назад)
It’s oct. 2018. CNN sucks. Morgan is a liar. Bye bye R v. Wade. God is so goooood
Rup Tratin (3 месяца назад)
"Again it comes back to changing times." Times just change, guys. Things just happen, and progress is always good because things are changing with no catalyst or agenda.
javier castellon (3 месяца назад)
Good is good today, tomorrow and always. Evil is evil today, tomorrow and always. The premeditated killing of the innocent is, and will always be and objective evil.
Sara S (3 месяца назад)
Yes, it was not an issue because no none thought to make it an issue then. Jerry Falwell who started the Liberty University in 1970s aimed at using social and religious hot buttons (interracial dating at that time) to score political gains, would have never dreamed of having taken over the presidency, senate and the house today (and now the Supreme Court). All they had to do was to adjust the social hot buttons for the time, now abortion and immigration. Republicans of course know it is not about abortion, immigration or gun control, it is about stealing your money ...
Sara S (3 месяца назад)
And if you pay taxes, looked at the changes to deductions and brackets for this year with Trump tax? Every deduction applicable to the little guy is out, anything that help the high income pay less taxes is in. AMC (alternative min. tax) is eliminated yet you can no longer claim for employee expenses, or deduct your Roth IRA losses (both applied to middle income tax payers). This was truly a pay off to the rich, just look at what is changed and think why and who could have asked for them ... This is what I mean by stealing your money ...
Sara S (3 месяца назад)
And you probably voted for Trump. If you did and are not one of the 30% evangelicals who are brained washed into thinking Trump, with all his obvious flaws, is their savior who will finally gives them their single wish of being able to force women to keep a pregnancy against their wish, if you are not one of the blue color miners who just had it with being ignored, scared of losing your dying coal mining job, and if you are not a white racist with nostalgia for the America's racist past; if you weren't any of these and still voted for this piece of work, I have to question your intelligence ....
javier castellon (3 месяца назад)
Dear Sara. You have been thoroughly and completely brainwashed by the liberal media.
Stephen Heyer (3 месяца назад)
Now that Scalia kicked the bucket who’s gonna think for Clarence Thomas?
Randy Bailin (3 месяца назад)
Scalia's looking at Morgan like he's talking to a complete imbecile.
Gregory Wells (3 месяца назад)
Slavery was left up to democratic choice, too, though. So, did he think the Confederacy should have been allowed to keep their human slaves? This argument is nonsense. Civil rights matter more than democracy.
myForumDaily (3 месяца назад)
"Civil rights matter more than democracy." and who gives you those rights? another human being??
William Fickett (3 месяца назад)
Piers Morgan what a dick, maybe he should work on his own country which is in the toilet. I’m surprise that he is interviewing Scalia who was A Giant intellect. Piers is such a beta male.
Bronx one zero 466 (3 месяца назад)
Roe V rode was base on a lied.nust like Mrs Ford allegations base on lies
Bronx one zero 466 (3 месяца назад)
Over turned it.
RefusesCookies (3 месяца назад)
Scalia was murdered.
Aaron Davis (3 месяца назад)
Scalia is a beast....
Coach Chris (3 месяца назад)
Abortion is murder of God's Creation
Jorge Johnson (3 месяца назад)
Leaving abortion rights to the individual states creates a slew of problems. Many women in non-abortion states would likely be retained until they are too far along in their pregnancies to travel to an abortion state. Scalia is disingenuous when he suggests that the founders cared about their wives and daughters when they didn’t even give them the basic right to vote. Morgan wasn’t prepared to challenge Scalia, but his point is clear. Without the basic right to vote you have nothing. Others decide what you can and cannot do. That is not freedom.
Chris Coulter (3 месяца назад)
Roe v. Wade should be reversed and send the abortion issue back to the individual states where it belongs. Women and California and New York can continue murdering their unborn children and other states can decide to outlaw it.
javier castellon (3 месяца назад)
The Democrat party is not pro -women.  Abortion is linked to regret, anxiety, low self stem, infertility, promiscuity, addictions and even suicide.  Abortion kills one, hurts another.
javier castellon (3 месяца назад)
What is good today is good tomorrow was good yesterday and will for ever be good.  What was bad yesterday, is bad today and will for ever be bad.  Abortion was admitted due to a penumbra in the constitution, about the right to privacy.  A big lie.  But of course, it had to be.  Orchestrated by "the father of lies", and "a murderer from the beginning".  The Devil Himself.  Unfortunately Satan being embodied by the Democrat party.
moon shot43 (3 месяца назад)
Scalia splitting hairs and focusing on the parts of the questions he finds absurd and ignoring those parts he simply doesn't want to answer because his answers will reveal a bias he wants to pretend doesn't exist. A true con artist.
MyRandomization (3 месяца назад)
A completely naive and ignorant argument. We don't need a world of unloved and damaged people in a world that's already overpopulated. His mindset is one of silver spoonfed priviliged wishy washy distance from ugly reality.
mrekbass (3 месяца назад)
"Justice" Scalia is a dead piece of shit asshole! So long prick! He's seated directly next to Satan and Hitler in Hell!
solarpaneling (3 месяца назад)
scalia have a uterus? ever pregnant? ever raped?
darthvader5300 (3 месяца назад)
IF YOU WOMEN HAVE THE HUMAN RGHT TO LIVE YOUR OWN WAY OF LIFE THEN THE UNBORN CHILD IN YOU ALSO DESERVE THE SAME HUMAN RIGHT TO LIVE IT'S OWN WAY OF LIFE BY WAY OF BEING ALLOWED TO LIVE, DEVELOP, AND BE BORN INTO THIS WORLD. IF YOU DON'T WANT YOUR BABY THEN THE STATE WILL ADOPT IT TO PROTECT IT'S HUMAN RIGHTS FOR THE UNBORN IN ALL OF IT'S STAGES OF DEVELOPMENT HAS THE SAME HUMAN RIGHTS JUST AS YOU WOMEN HAVE YOUR OWN HUMAN RIGHTS.
BroNumsi (3 месяца назад)
Wow, Scalia is coming of as either stupid, ironic or disingenuous, and I know he isn't stupid. "Whaaat? Why shouldn't they have had any rights when the constitution was written?" Due process? Sure. But they didn't have any other rights. New York passed their Married Women's Property Law in 1848. Before that, under the common law legal doctrine known as coverture, a married woman in Great Britain's North American colonies and later in the United States had hardly any legal existence apart from her husband. Her rights and obligations were subsumed under his. She could not own property, enter into contracts, or earn a salary. So the question of abortions at that time is just moot, and Scalia knows it.
kwazooplayingguardsman (3 месяца назад)
"She could not own property, enter into contracts, or earn a salary." This is utter fallacy, Coverture laws do pair two bodies into a single legal authority but it does not forbade women from owning property, enter into contracts, nor earn a salary, heck the entire notion of alimony many marriage and divorce settlements that is used to protect women has its heritage on coverture laws since those laws were made to protect women from instances of infidelity, death, or neglect by their husbands.
Elvira Donaghy (3 месяца назад)
He is a just judge. He is like our LORD JESUS CHRIST, who said "Thou shalt not KILL.". I will say FOR THE LIVES OF ALL CHILDREN, ABORTION SHOULD NOT BE LEGAL. STOP IMMORALITY. LOVE PURITY. DO NOT HAVE RELATIONS BEFORE BEING MARRIED IN THE EYES OF GOD THIS IS TRUE AND JUST. LIVE THE WAY GOD WANTS US TO AND YOU WILL SEE HAPPINESS ON EARTH.NOT DEATH AND DESTROYING OF HELPLESS BABIES INSIDE THEIR MOTHERS WOMBS. HOW TERRIBLE. TO TAKE YOUR OWN FLESH AND BLOOD AND KILL IT IN YOUR OWN BODY. JUST LIKE THE HEATHEN IN THE OLD TESTAMENT THEY OFFERED THE BLOOD SACRIFICE OF THEIR BABIES AND CHILDREN TO MOLOCH. THE DEVIL. SO IS THIS ABORTION. NONE OF YOU WILL EVER HAVE PEACE NOR BE HAPPY SO LONG AS ABORTION IS ACCEPTABLE IN THIS COUNTRY AND THE WORLD.
jbond5150 (3 месяца назад)
Thats cute that that loudmouthed fuck pretends that he doesnt care if abortion is illegal or not. Of course he cares. Hes been an antichoice catholic his whole life.
kwazooplayingguardsman (3 месяца назад)
+jbond5150 saying that you cannot divorce the individual from a company and then restrict an individual's right by treating him as part of a collective is a principled stance. Just like I can't forbid the expression of tabloidic newspapers even when we know it's a company that is in the business of shaping opinions. There is no right to privacy, there are specific rights that pertains to one's privacy in the bill of rights but no one is arguing against that. What people are arguing about is substantial due process, the belief that there are rights that cannot be revoked even with due process and there was no such provision in the constitution about such a thing.
jbond5150 (3 месяца назад)
kwazooplayingguardsman saying corporations are people is a good principle? Or that there is no inherent right to privacy... thats a good principle huh? Idiot.
kwazooplayingguardsman (3 месяца назад)
they're pretty great principles.
jbond5150 (3 месяца назад)
kwazooplayingguardsman no doubt hes principled. Theyre just the wrong principles.
kwazooplayingguardsman (3 месяца назад)
as if yours isn't influenced and clouded by your rabid anti-religiosity. A smart man admits that he has natural biases, a principled man knows when to drop them and when it is right to exercise them and I have no qualms with principled men.
Gary C (3 месяца назад)
Piers Morgan has no standing to challenge Scalia. He's embarrassing himself.
Jeremy Smith (3 месяца назад)
Haha. This is awesome. Piers got his A handed to him. What a moron.
Samuel Arana Tessari (3 месяца назад)
Morgan is such a lightweight.. Not even his British accent can make him sound smart
William Ross (3 месяца назад)
Justice Scalia was an intelligent man! If they want abortions put it in the constitution!
Ronald Schraa (3 месяца назад)
What a idiot young people go out and vote
kwazooplayingguardsman (3 месяца назад)
I'm 20 years old and I'm voting for conservatives.
Mark Armage (3 месяца назад)
Justice Scalia made one simple mistake, the right to privacy can't triumph the basic right even more important than that, it's the right of life. And by his judgement, he isn't consider a unborn baby a living thing, want to know better, sir, go to an Abortion Clinic and see whether the remains of an unborn looks more like a bunch of cells or an actual baby body. Wrong judgement.
Walt Schmidt (3 месяца назад)
Why have all these limeys invaded American media outlets?
networkdeath1 (3 месяца назад)
Let’s give women the vote, they seem like rational beings. Right?
david jones (3 месяца назад)
i started to watch.... but i cant stand morgan.....
Rhett Reisman (3 месяца назад)
There are two different discussions happening: Piers thinks that abortion should be legal because women should be empowered. Scalia thinks we shouldn't be flippantly adding amendments to the constitution because most changes should be left to the states - saying nothing about whether abortion should be legal or not. A great example of why we need underlying principles to dictate our decision making. Scalia is absolutely right.
R Good (3 месяца назад)
Send more ice. It's hot down here.
darthvader5300 (3 месяца назад)
Keep your laws off my body? Well then if you want to keep OTHER PEOPLE off your body through their laws so that you can live freely in your own way. THEN THE UNBORN CHILDREN IN ALL OF IT'S STAGES OF DEVELOPMENT ALSO HAS A RIGHT TO KEEP OTHER PEOPLE (THAT INCLUDES IT'S MOTHER OR FATHER OR BOTH PARENTS) OFF THEIR BODIES AS WELL SO THAT THEY CAN ALSO LIVE FREELY IN IT'S OWN WAY TOO AND IN ORDER FOR IT TO DO THAT IT MUST BE ALLOWED TO BE FULLY MATURED AND BE BORN INTO THIS WORLD TOO JUST AS YOU WERE BORN INTO THIS WORLD TOO!
1400IntruderVS (3 месяца назад)
I find it funny how a person can spend their intellect in search of a reason outside all morality to argue for the availability of abortions but somehow their ignorant of how to avoid needing access to such a barbaric practice.
razzledingle (3 месяца назад)
Scalia is stunned at Piers Morgan's infantile grasp of the subject.
Mel Gonzalez (3 месяца назад)
Pig
Tyrant Toaster (3 месяца назад)
You can see moments where they cut this together to prevent Scalia from giving a more complete argument. Namely at 2:28 when it cuts back to him
Mark Johnson (3 месяца назад)
Piers Morgan trying to argue the law with Scalia was/is a joke. Its analogous to me telling Ted Williams how to hit a baseball. Scalia is two years dead and he's still smarter than Morgan.
Yual Chiek (3 месяца назад)
Hahaha it is just silly how much Scalia intellectually outclasses Morgan!
svenmega10022 (3 месяца назад)
I can see Justice Scalia's thought process here. A determination to take life can not be made with out due legal process. The unborn cannot protect themselves. They have the right to due process before any determination can be made. Roe vs. Wade goes counter to that legal right to due process.
mrpro (3 месяца назад)
svenmega10022 your flat assertions ("take life") and loaded terms reveal your bias. he didn't say or allude to anything of the kind. i think it was much more complicated for him. Scalia considered himself a strict constructionist: if it is not written out in the constitution, the S.Ct has no power to decide it. i believe he wanted to reverse roe v wade on that basis. nevertheless, he joined the majority opinion in planned parenthood v casey, upholding the primary decision in roe, and preventing what he seemed to have thought was a greater harm. i don't think he ever expressed any concerns about "the unborn."
Feliciano Leon (3 месяца назад)
Scalia was a good jurist--- too bad he was murdered before his time.
Mr Nopy (3 месяца назад)
It would be better if it was left for individual states to decide to allow or deny abortion. The us is a big place and it’s quite understandable that it is nearly impossible to please all sides.
Patrick Modell (3 месяца назад)
Scalia is just a brilliant mind that this country misses oh so much since his passing. What an intellect yet so very humble and human.
Tim Constantine (3 месяца назад)
p morgan is super dumb......
abbyboyone (3 месяца назад)
The constitution like the Bible is up to interpretation.
William Sims (3 месяца назад)
And you don’t want 9 unelected officials, serving life terms, deciding that. Because it went your way, pro choice, is not a good reason. How about had it not?
AroundSun (3 месяца назад)
I wish Scalia schooled him hard on this, and told Piers that we don't just legislate changes to the constitution because its an old document, we have something called the amendment process which requires a different process. also, the view on abortion is that the baby IS a human being who cannot be deprived the right to life. then it comes down to when you believe life starts. his answer is acceptable though if you want to invoke the 10th amendment and leave the issue to the states.
JDD 07 (3 месяца назад)
The Judicial system is not the legislative branch
Frank Carr (3 месяца назад)
I do not think they thought it would ever be a federal issue. But abortion is a very ancient practice.
Deponensvogel (3 месяца назад)
The problem is, people are so much without any basic principles, that they simply can't get their head around the idea that you as a Supreme Court justice could make decisions not based on your political view, but on the ground of a legal document.
walkthisways (3 месяца назад)
He was murderedand never investigated.
Jesse M (3 месяца назад)
scaLIA IS DEAD.............PIECE OF SHIT.
Jake Jones (3 месяца назад)
I agree. The NERVE of this guy telling a woman that she has no right to murder her unborn baby!
Chuckie Waitt (3 месяца назад)
The way Piers Morgan talks down to Justice Scalia as if he's more knowledgable than Scalia on the topic is disgusting
Catherine Pham (3 месяца назад)
How did Justice Scalia agree to be interviewed by the idiot Morgan ?
ABC ABC (3 месяца назад)
QUEERS MORON
James Hansen (3 месяца назад)
Amend the Constitution if America wants abortion.
javier castellon (3 месяца назад)
Abortion was admitted due to a theory of substantive due process.  A penumbra in the constitution, about the right to privacy.  A big lie.  But of course, it had to be.  Orchestrated by "the father of lies", and "a murderer from the beginning".  The Devil Himself.  Unfortunately Satan being embodied by the Democrat party.
spacepatrolman (3 месяца назад)
Catholics don't have abortions so let the others kill their little bastards if they want to they usually overpopulate
Andrew Baroch (3 месяца назад)
..gulty-complex CNN, haunted by Scalia on abortion, which, like, you know, is killing babies...report that, plain English, CNN...
Coleen West (3 месяца назад)
Judge Scalia will be missed. I wish Piers hadn't interrupted him as he was getting into the meat of the issue - the world divided into "substance and procedure". I would have been interested in hearing his development of this argument. But Piers just stuttered his way into an interruption all the while not understanding that he just interrupted the important part.
JM L (3 месяца назад)
This is very relevant once again. Unfortunetly, Justic Scalia, RIP rested his laurels on the opinions of the founding fathers. Piers is annoying but the comment on relevancy of the times we live is like the bible, generally its got some good messages, and like the bible, the constituion has some pretty good ideas too but it was created during a time when women could not even vote never have a say wether or not to reject a pregnacy from an unwanted fetus. Especially in the case of rape, if you really want to argue that a fetus is human being, Love in the bow people. All men, and women, should have the right or say in what happens to their own body and to manage their lives and health accordingly.
Kevin Smith (3 месяца назад)
That last statement is the key. That is what Roe v Wade is, and that is why it was wrongly decided. On top of that Piers is a charlatan when comes to Constitutional jurisprudence.
Patrick Doyle (3 месяца назад)
If you looked up the definition of "outclassed" in the dictionary, there'd be a photograph of this conversation. Morgan's so out of his depth here I'm almost embarrassed for him.
Ms Mccoy (3 месяца назад)
What the heck is Morgan doing talking to Scalia .. Good Lord could they not find a more knowledgeable intelligent man. He should only be interviewing pop stars and actors
mayukh keelar (3 месяца назад)
I feel like Morgan’s abrupt questioning of Scalia’s stance on the legality of abortion following an in depth analysis of the perspectives of due process in the status quo show that he simply cannot hold a conversation with scalia
leafyutube (3 месяца назад)
I wanna be a suprem court judge but where do you start?
Amy Neuhart (3 месяца назад)
leafyutube I would suggest a good jumping off point would be spelling "suprem" with a second E. Lol. 😉

Хотите оставить комментарий?

Присоединитесь к YouTube, или войдите, если вы уже зарегистрированы.